Single Family Home for Sale in Edgartown, #41186

Welcome to this exquisite North Water Street Captain's compound, where luxury meets charm. Originally known as the Captain Silva house, this remarkable property offers a 7-bed, 7.5-bath main house, set to be completed by Spring 2024. Additionally, the property offers a charming 1-bed, 1-bath guest house spanning 900 square feet and a 2-car carriage house featuring a 1-bed, 1-bath living space of 400 square feet, both of which are Spring 2023 new constructions.

With captivating harbor views, this generational home is a true masterpiece designed by renowned architect Patrick Ahearn, reimagined with timeless design and modern finishes. Indulge in the ultimate relaxation with a 16’ x 32’ saltwater pool and spa, complemented by a pool cabana, all set in a private backyard oasis.

History intertwines with contemporary living, creating an extraordinary and must-see property. Don't miss the opportunity to call this exceptional home yours, where cherished memories await to be made.

Floor 1: Main House - first-floor bedroom, office, parlor, dining room, kitchen, living room, & covered porch.


Guest House - kitchen, full bath, living room, laundry

Floor 2: Main House - 4 bedrooms with ensuite baths, laundry room.


Guest House - 1 bedroom

Basement: New 8' Poured Concrete Foundation

Other Buildings: 1 BD 1 BA 900 SF Guest House.
2-Car Carriage House w/1 BD 1 BA 400 SF Bedroom.
Pool Cabana w/wet bar - sink, dishwasher, fridge, & freezer.

Second Dwelling: Secondary Dwelling: A 2023 new construction guest house spanning 900 square feet is positioned at the rear of the property, ensuring both privacy and tranquility. Notably, its aesthetic and quality match that of the main house, pool cabana, and carriage house, maintaining a consistent fit and finish throughout. Furthermore, an unfinished basement is accessible via a bulkhead entrance, providing an opportune space for additional storage.



Tertiary Dwelling: A 2023 new construction carriage house w/bedroom and pool cabana, positioned at the midway point of the property. It features a 2-car carriage house with a second floor 400 square foot bedroom with a full bath. Additionally, a pool cabana is attached at the rear, facing the pool and guest house.